When you're involved in a custody battle, one of the most important things you can do is understand how a judge thinks. It could very well be the factor that determines whether you win or lose your case. Many people walk into court assuming all they need to do is tell their side of the story—but family law doesn’t work like that. Judges follow specific principles, and if you’re unaware of what matters to them, you could be wasting time—or worse, sabotaging your case.

The Importance of Knowing a Custody Judge’s Mindset

My name is Kyle Kaufman, and I’m a family law attorney at HKK Law Offices in Wisconsin. Over the years, I’ve learned a great deal about how judges approach custody cases, and understanding their mindset can dramatically improve your chances. In this article, I’ll walk you through some key insights based on an interview I read with a custody judge. We’ll touch on topics like child custody in the first year of life, common family court issues, the role of attorneys, attorney fees, and settlement agreements. Stick around until the end for some valuable information from this interview.

1. It’s All About the Child’s Best Interests

Above all, judges are concerned with what’s best for the child. Family law judges don’t care about what’s fair to you—they care about the child’s well-being. This means they focus on factors like:

• Which parent can provide the most stability?
• Who is actively involved in the child’s daily life?
• Can the parents communicate and co-parent effectively?

If your argument centers on badmouthing your ex without connecting it to the child’s well-being, the judge won’t be interested. It’s vital to keep the child’s best interests front and center in your case.

2. Judges Have a Lot of Discretion

Custody cases are complex and filled with gray areas. Unlike criminal law, where things are more black-and-white, family law judges have significant discretion. Every judge has their own perspective on what’s best for a child.

Some judges prefer joint custody whenever possible, while others lean toward maintaining stability, meaning they may favor the parent who has been the primary caregiver. By understanding your judge’s tendencies, you can tailor your approach to improve your chances of success.

3. Credibility is Key

Judges don’t just listen to what you say—they pay attention to how you say it. Do you appear calm, reasonable, and focused on your child’s well-being? Or do you seem angry, combative, or unwilling to co-parent? Your tone, body language, and even facial expressions can all impact how the judge perceives you. Staying composed and showing respect for the process can help establish your credibility.

4. Avoid Common Mistakes

One of the fastest ways to lose credibility in court is to make unsupported accusations or badmouth the other parent. Judges are used to hearing extreme claims, but unless you have solid evidence that the other parent poses a danger to the child, these accusations can backfire. Instead, stick to the facts and focus on what you bring to the table as a parent.

5. Use Your Knowledge to Your Advantage

Understanding what a judge is likely to prioritize can help you make smarter decisions both in court and during settlement negotiations. If you can show that your position aligns with the judge’s focus on the child’s best interests, you’re in a much stronger position. Avoid arguments that aren’t backed by solid evidence or relevance—these types of disputes only increase costs and stress.

6. How to Learn About Your Judge

So, how can you get to know your judge better? Here are some strategies:

• Ask your attorney: Attorneys often have experience with particular judges and can provide insights into their tendencies.
• Consult with other attorneys: A broader network of attorneys might have useful feedback on a specific judge.
• Research online: If your judge was elected, campaign materials or public records may shed light on their preferences and values.
• Use social media: Sometimes, you can find community feedback on a judge’s past decisions or approach.
• Observe in court: Courtrooms are generally open to the public, so sitting in on a hearing might give you a sense of how the judge operates.
• Read articles and interviews: Some judges write articles or give interviews that reveal their philosophy on family law.

7. Insights from a Custody Judge Interview

I recently came across an interview with a custody judge, and I want to share some of the insights from that conversation. Here are a few key takeaways:

• On equal overnight placement for fathers with infants: When asked about whether it’s appropriate to award significant overnight placement to fathers with children under a year old, the judge explained that bonding during infancy is critical. Unless a father is unable or unwilling to meet the infant’s needs, they should be given significant, recurring overnight placement to establish a bond with the child.
• Common issues in family law: The judge highlighted challenges like differing perspectives on online schooling, parents' work schedules, and the evolving economic situations of families. Another issue that frequently arises is motions to limit one parent’s ability to travel with the children, which the judge typically sees as a parenting issue rather than a legal one.
• On parent coordinators: Parent coordinators can play a significant role, but the judge weighs their decisions on a case-by-case basis, considering the experience of the coordinator and the history with the family.
• What impresses a judge about attorneys: The judge appreciates attorneys who come prepared and are willing to attempt to reach a compromise. It’s disappointing when attorneys see a case as something to be fully litigated rather than focusing on solutions that benefit the children in the long term.
• Attorney fees in contempt cases: When a parent violates a custody order, the judge rarely awards attorney fees unless there is a history of blatant contemptuous behavior. When fees are awarded, they’re determined based on factors like the history of the parties, the work involved, and the financial situations of the parties.

Conclusion

The answers provided by this judge offer valuable insights into the priorities that shape their decisions. By understanding how a custody judge thinks, you can frame your case in a way that aligns with their values, improving your chances of a favorable outcome. Remember: the key to success in custody battles is focusing on what’s best for the child, staying credible, and making informed choices based on your judge’s mindset.

I encourage you to learn as much as you can about the judge overseeing your case. This knowledge is one of your most powerful tools in navigating family law matters.

These are complicated matters, and the point of me sharing this information with you is to make you aware of these matters and to help you explore the ideas and concepts. 

Thank you for reading. Can you do something for me so we can continue to make great content like this?

1. Schedule a complimentary consultation to speak with us using Wisconsin Attorney | Random Lake, WI | Hawley, Kaufman & Kautzer S.C.
2. Subscribe or follow HKK Law Offices on social media
3. Like and share our social media posts
4. Leave a comment on our social media posts